Skip to main content

Dream Theater - The Astonishing [ALBUM REVIEW/IMPRESSIONS]

The Astonishing is an ambitious double album with a storyline that echoes Star Wars and Game of Thrones. Hard to follow and a little too complex – the concept for Dream Theater’s 13th album would be tolerable if only the music made up for it. The album ricochets a little too familiar with Rush’s 2112 but this is understandable given both bands connections and contributions to the progressive genre. 

The single release of “The Gift of Music” was promising, but with 34 tracks – a few of which are fillers with less than 1 minute and 30 seconds of random noises –  the album is difficult to grasp onto at first and second listen. The album lasts a total of 2 hours and 9 minutes and at least a quarter of that shines as some of Dream Theater’s finest work – the rest however, feels multifaceted and tedious.
Vocalist James LaBrie performs each character himself in first-person. The versatility of his voice shows throughout the album but there are parts you definitely think could benefit from additional vocalists or narration like the concept albums you hear from the likes of Ayreon, Avantasia and Devin Townsend. The drums feel a little bit lacklustre at times which is upsetting as we all know what Mike Mangini is capable of.
The single “Chosen” for example is a beautiful love ballad and shows how dynamic LaBrie and keyboardist Jordan Rudess can be. Sadly, though, the song feels as though it needs a female vocalist providing backing and could even benefit from being a duet with said female singer. The album is filled with these types of ballads – all of which follow the same formula.
The album benefits from a full orchestra, performed by the City of Prague Philarmonic, and is arranged by the legendary David Campbell, who is no stranger to rock music nowadays, but even the bombastic choir and orchestra arrangements don’t bring out the power of the music that is featured on The Astonishing. 

In closing my brief but to-the-point impressions of Dream Theater’s The Astonishing I say it’s not a bad album, just maybe not what you’ve come to expect from the progressive giants. It’s worth checking out and is guaranteed to blow many people away as their finest efforts and maybe it will grow on you – but overall, The Astonishing is yet another over-hyped record.


Popular posts from this blog

Surround Sound: It's getting stupid, stop surrounding yourself.

3 in front and 2 behind? Perfect 3 in front, 2 behind and 2 at each adjacent side of your room? Great idea! Anything more? okay relax.

I upgraded to a 7.1 Channel system this weekend and needless to say, for audio and gaming it does the job superbly well - but why literally surround yourself? We have two ears. When it comes to audio I think that 2 channels are enough, with 5.1 DVD-A being a niche market that's awesome when done properly (Steven Wilson's mixes are genius)

22.2 surround sound (or Hamasaki 22.2 as it's called) is excessive. Ridiculous amounts of wiring and the idea of upmixing your stereo/5.1/7.1 channels is hellish but doable, but will we actually begin mixing things in true 22.2 channel format? Time will tell. (admittedly some orchestral arrangements would sound freaking brilliant if each instrument is given a dedicated speaker)

The Saab 99 Restoration Begins!

So the other day I was kindly gifted a Saab 99 by a Saab club member and friend. This 1973 Toreador red was last on the road in 2012 according to the registration sticker on the back window and was one of three rescued from Yarraman in Queensland (about 250km away from my place) So far it's not running, but an ignition coil and condenser should fix that. Then to do an oil and filter change as it's probably like tar. Despite the insanely wet weather here, I've been washing the car and polishing her up and bringing that red to life. The windscreen needed resealing so she suffered a little bit of water in the front but nothing too major.
I'll keep you all posted.

Mike Portnoy referenced in Dream Theater's "The Looking Glass"?

Studying the lyrics of "The Looking Glass", track 3 on Dream Theater's latest album "DREAM THEATER" I began to wonder if the lyrics focus on those who use social media and the internet to make sure people continue to know of their presence. More significantly, was Petrucci thinking of former drummer Mike Portnoy?

I would not expect you felt unnoticed and ignored
Better to rise above the clouds (Black Clouds was the last DT album Portnoy appeared on)
Than be a stranger in the crowd

All that you protected doesn't matter anymore
Rather be stripped of all your pride
Than watch your dreams be cast aside (Portnoy stated that he had other dreams to pursue, perhaps he cast “Dream Theater” aside?)

You are caught up in your gravity
Glorifying stardom
Singing your own praise

You live without shame
You're digging up a gold mine
Standing on the sidelines
Watching through the looking glass

You are not content with being nameless and unknown (Attempts to stay in th…